What Is Our Budget, How Does It Work? What Is Thoughtful Spending?
Budgeting is hard. Who likes to budget? Do you have a budget for your household? I hope you do, but I know many people do not. They struggle to create one, and even when they do, it's hard to track and maintain it. You have to be very data-driven — and I've been told pretty nerdy! — to do this well.
I love budgets and numbers.
Budgets allow you to (a) map a course of action, (b) see how you're doing relative to your plan, and (c) make adjustments based on what happens in real life. They are a vision and an active plan. They paint a picture of where you are and where you want to go.
As much as I love budgets and numbers, I'll admit that school budgets are an entirely different animal. They budget in a way that is different from what I'm used to, having built dozens of budgets for my companies over the years. School budgets make it truly hard to do the "in-process" analysis that allows you to know exactly how you're doing.
With that said, we do know enough about our budget to get some guidance on where we are, particularly relative to our peers. And I do commit to becoming an expert on school budgets once I am on the BOE and can talk with the State Monitor and other financial experts more specifically than I can as a resident.
Having looked at our budget, I do know that our top expenses are (a) teacher salaries, (b) payments to Charter Schools, and (c) building maintenance. It's also likely that teacher benefits are up there, although it's not broken out in an obvious way.
Breaking it down further, and based on the information I have, there is the possibility of updating the budget in a thoughtful manner. This would include possible rightsizing in the following areas:
- Administrative consolidation — this has already started, and it's possible an additional $750K–$1.5M/yr could be saved in this area.
- Facilities and operations — we have to wait for the building study, but we could save up to $3M/yr in operational costs alone by closing buildings.
- Benefits, contracts, and transportation — benefit costs alone could save us significant money relative to what's being paid now, without diminishing offerings to the staff.
- Charter school payments — with more detailed data analytics and verifying the residency of all Charter School students, we could save money by not paying for children who don't reside in Asbury Park.
None of the above includes any cuts to teachers. With that being said, as a Board Member I would ask for a full report of the curriculum and staff to understand who is teaching what, and where we may have overlap or underutilization. I want as many teachers as we need to give our students the education they deserve. I have spoken with teachers in the district and have heard several suggestions for improving learning in the classroom that I will share with our new Superintendent.
Bottom line: until we create, track, and update our budget and monitor our spending, we will never know exactly where our money is going and how much of that is reaching the students. I want the ability to do both.